Not only do they misrepresent the powerful benefit for good that flows out of the gospel of Jesus Christ, but also much of the positive influence of the family of God throughout history. However, to say religion is the cause of war is perhaps mistaken. Wars of Religion, (1562–98) conflicts in France between Protestants and Roman Catholics. History simply does not support the hypothesis that religion is the major cause of conflict. We and our partners will store and/or access information on your device through the use of cookies and similar technologies, to display personalised ads and content, for ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. Jesus also chose Matthew, a tax collector—or if you like, a collaborator with the Empire. RELIGION CAUSES WAR: PROS AND CONS There are many arguments and counter-arguments when discussing the topic of religion causing war. Take away a humans natural capacity for aggression, greed and self-preservation and what you have left are his positive traits and his values which generally serve as the basis of our religions. In these classes I learned about many cultures, religious, and Wars. My prayer is that, far from contributing to the rather erroneous view that religion causes all wars, Christians would witness to the world that Christ our saviour has broken every wall. The question as to whether religion causes war is as controversial as the comparison of religions themselves. The spread of French Calvinism persuaded the French ruler Catherine de Médicis to show more tolerance for the Huguenot s, which angered the powerful Roman Catholic Guise family. of The Salvation Army. Most religions specify that violence is not allowed and yet extremists will cause major destruction in the name of their God. This comes from our innate tendency to want other people to … This kind of religiously-motivated outbreak of peace has often been overlooked. The alarming conclusion I’ve come to is that religion is the primary cause of war. Religion and ideology are both secondary causes for war. To demonstrate this point, let’s look at the 20th century. ‘Irreligion’ is a greater cause of war than religion. 125 likes. Many wars have led to large numbers of people leaving their countries yearning for a better life. For example, at the Munk Debate in Toronto last November, Christopher Hitchens argued this very point against Tony Blair. If you are an atheist, I ask … Fought after the Protestant Reformation began in 1517, the wars disrupted the religious and political order in the Catholic countries of Europe. Through much of my life I was forced to sit through a history class. The first is when people try to compel other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives. In New Zealand, the peace that first came to Maori through Christianity initially resulted in increasingly peaceful relations between various Iwi. Religion Causes War." For example, at the Munk Debate in Toronto last November, Christopher Hitchens argued this very point against Tony Blair. If religion can‟t be blamed for most wars and violence, then whatis the primary cause? Religion, Hitchens claimed, causes sectarianism, division, strife, disagreement, war, poverty and a host of societal evils. Thought needs to be given on how to respond to this. Religion prevents our children from having a rational education; religion prevents us from removing the fundamental causes of war; religion prevents us from teaching the ethic of scientific co-operation in place of the old fierce doctrines of sin and punishment. Religion causes war. Even if there were a world with no religion, there would still be war. Religion causes war. War and religion: I don't think religion can be looked at as a "cause" for war. Certainly, there are real issues around the potential risk to innocent people when terrorists carry out their immoral plans. The first is when people try to compel other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives. An essentially peaceful religion can become more violent and aggressive in its thinking when it is imbedded in a people who live in a climate of fear, violence and humiliation. There are at least three instances by which religion causes war. With the regularity that we hear the mantra ‘religion is the cause of all wars’, it would be easy to become disenchanted in our faith. Does religion cause most wars? New Zealand, Fiji, Tonga & Samoa Territory. There are numerous examples of religious wars. It is said so often that people believe it without question. The historical evidence is quite clear: Religion is not the #1 cause of war. © Copyright 2021, The Salvation Army New Zealand, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa Territory. Germans living in New Zealand during World War I and II experienced this. This left them open to religious leaders who espoused a more aggressive theology that sometimes emphasised violent Old Testament themes. However, with the land wars, the loss of land, devastating epidemics and the loss of mana, Maori experienced huge disillusionment and despair. Religion causes war. This could seem a good way of lifting the Christian banner higher. Therefore, the aim is to prove that religion is more of an excuse for war. We can easily remember the Crusades, which were nothing but a war between Christians and Muslims, civil conflicts between Catholics and Protestants in England and Northern Ireland, wars between the Sunnis and the Shiites in Muslim countries. The wars of the ancient world were rarely, if ever, based on religion. RELIGION CAUSES WAR: PROS AND CONS There are many arguments and counter-arguments when discussing the topic of religion causing war. Islam bans the killing of non-combatants (Qur'an 2:190, above), or of a combatant who has been captured. The first is when people try to compel other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives. In the modern period, debates are common over the extent to which religious, economic, or ethnic aspects of a conflict predominate in a given war. However, the primary cause for all war is sin. Religion appeals to myth and symbol, and politics "mimics" this appeal in devotion to the flag, war memorials, and so on. Jews have committed genocide over nations for the sole reason to fulfill their cause. There are at least three instances by which religion causes war. A better understanding of other people’s faiths, along with the context underlying their belief and behaviour, is part of ‘loving our neighbour’—or doing unto others what we sometimes wish our secular friends would do unto us, when they dismissively judge our Christianity. He spoke to and about Samaritans in a positive way, despite the prevailing view of disdain and even hatred for Samaritans at that time. Religion causes war. A religious war or holy war (Latin: bellum sacrum) is a war primarily caused or justified by differences in religion.In the modern period, debates are common over the extent to which religious, economic, or ethnic aspects of a conflict predominate in a given war. What causes war are the traits of human beings in general. I participated recently in a time of prayer for peace. In his research on Christian churches and genocide in that country, Timothy Longman notes the extensive criticism faced by that country’s Christian churches, not only for failing to oppose the genocide, but for complicity in the violence. Our view of Christianity and its relation to war and violence is a subject worthy of thought, as we seek to shape our faith in a way that reflects the love we have for God and as we seek to honour him. In that context it can be hard to determine whether the religion was intrinsically evil and violent, or was ‘turned’ that way by the extreme context it existed within. The article also claims that, “Blaming only religion is as incorrect as blaming only ethnic groups, ideologues, persons identifying with a certain country or class struggle.” I personally do not believe that religion is what causes war. Let's first address the claim that religion causes most wars and look at the actual statistics throughout history to refute this nonsense. Many critics argue that throughout history, religion has been the single greatest source of human-caused wars, suffering, and misery. Religion divides people into separate groups and tells them that they are incompatible with each other. A common misperception of Christianity and religion is the claim that most violence and war is caused by religious belief/intolerance. A religion of violence. Religion has often acted as a corrective to state violence, with variations of the ‘do unto others what you would like others to do unto you’ golden rule, which is not only found in Christianity. Fought after the Protestant Reformation began in 1517, the wars disrupted the religious and political order in the Catholic countries of Europe. Religion puts a check on political power, and tyrannical regimes suppress it. The first is when people try to compel other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives. The question as to whether religion causes war is as controversial as the comparison of religions themselves. Jesus broke down so many walls. Likewise, the war had a devastating impact on church membership and activities, so the state of home front religion became a constant concern for both sides throughout the war. Does Religion Cause War Argumentative Essay. This was only possible because of their religious convictions. . Atheists often claim that religion fuels aggressive wars, both because it exacerbates antagonisms between opponents and also because it gives aggressors confidence by making them feel as if they have God on their side. Religion is not the main cause of war, according to a new report. The war in 1991 in Yugoslavia pitted Catholic, Orthodox Christians, and Muslims against each other in a very bloody war. The Jewish Rabbi prayed that violence would not define us and our religion. No wonder, then, that a violent and reactive kind of religion has appealed to some. Religion puts a check on political power, and tyrannical regimes suppress it. So often is this sentiment heard in the best sellers from Richard Dawkins to Sam Harris that it has almost become a proverb. Information about your device and internet connection, including your IP address, Browsing and search activity while using Verizon Media websites and apps. But the War Audit set out to identify conflicts that were more closely linked to religious belief than to political causes - that could most properly be called religious wars. Then refute that selfishness, greed, and sin caused by human-violence are the primary causes of war. Through much of my life I was forced to sit through a history class. The racism and ghettoization of Islamic people in France has been identified by many as a likely contextual factor that could lead disaffected young people toward the kind of violence that is now emerging there. Richard Dawkins has put it this way: “Religion causes war by generating certainty”. Think of the French revolution (the birthplace of the secular state), Communist Russia, the regimes of the Shah of Iran and Ataturk in Turkey, not to mention Hitler’s Germany. The accusation that religion causes war is especially simplistic when applied to the pre-modern era. religion is just the fuel they use to get people to fight for them, as it is easier to get some to fight for something they belief in than getting them to fight on your side. Richard Dawkins has put it this way: “Religion causes war by generating certainty”. In fact, communism is by definition an atheistic ideology. This is a matter of historical fact. Religion uses rites and ceremonies, such as circumcision and baptism, and "[p]olitics also depends on rites and ceremonies," even in avowedly secular nations. The main Christian view of war ethics is contained in the doctrine of the Just War.. Religion causes war. Many theories have been put forth over the years as to why wars happen, and some of the greatest minds have offered their take on the subject. And John Lennon encouraged us to: Instead, war is caused by clashes between different groups, bad government, high levels of corruption and poor relations with neighbouring countries. Connect with us on LinkedIn. www.confidentchristians.org 14. Wouldn’t it have been interesting to hear Simon and Matthew talk about their view of the Kingdom they were hoping Jesus would initiate? He says church personnel and institutions ‘were actively involved in the programme of resistance to popular pressures for political reform that culminated in the 1994 genocide, and numerous priests, pastors, nuns, brothers, catechists, and Catholic and Protestant lay leaders supported, participated in, or helped to organize the killings.’ Given that both Catholic and Protestant churches in Rwanda were multi-ethnic, this means that ‘in most communities members of a church parish killed their fellow parishioners and even, in a number of cases, their own pastor or priest’. Religion can get caught up in war. This argument has the advantage of having some validity. However, to say religion is the cause of war is perhaps mistaken. "Religion causes wars" The British zoologist Richard Dawkins says that "religion causes wars by generating certainty". Religion can get caught up in war. Causes of the Wars of Religion. There are at least three instances by which religion causes war. Mahatma Ghandi, Martin Luther King, Archbishop Desmond Tutu—and here in New Zealand the Maori prophets Te Whiti o Rongomai and Tohu Kakahi at Parihaka—are  clear examples of religious leaders who did much to avert violence by refusing to use it, even for what they clearly saw as a just cause. It would seem that too often the love of God does not work sufficiently in our lives that it reaches to our neighbour and that we do not always meet the call of Jesus to ‘love our enemies’. Wars fought for culture often wrongly appear to be fought for religion. Longman’s research confirms these conclusions. Religion causes war. by Ian Hutson(c) 'War Cry' magazine, 12-13 March 2015, pp9. In these classes I learned about many cultures, religious, and Wars. The article also claims that, “Blaming only religion is as incorrect as blaming only ethnic groups, ideologues, persons identifying with a certain country or class struggle.” I personally do not believe that religion is what causes war. However, the answer is “no” in the sense that religion is never the primary cause of war. And John Lennon encouraged us to: The same thing that triggers all crime,cruelty, loss of life, and other such things… www.confidentchristians.org 15. However a through examination of history reveals that that most of causes of wars and suffering are in fact secular, even the so-called "religious wars" that were The Crusades. Both religion and atheism can be … I would argue that a major cause of most (but not all) wars is religion. There are at least three instances by which religion causes war. The religion of Nazi Germany was the state, and the religion of Stalinist Russia was socialism. Observing all this, it is easy to come to the conclusion that religion often causes wars. You can read 'War Cry' at your nearest Salvation Army church or centre, or subscribe through Salvationist Resources. Since time immemorial, men have fought each other in wars caused by religion. 951 Words | 4 Pages. Atheists and secular humanists consistently make the claim that religion is the #1 cause of violence and war throughout the history of mankind. A World Council of Churches team that visited Rwanda in August 1994 reported: ‘In every conversation we had with the government and church people alike, the point was brought home to us that the church itself stands tainted, not by passive indifference, but by errors of commission as well.’. Most of us arrive on this earth with a fierce cry of protest. The prayers were held in a Mosque, and leaders of the three great monotheistic faiths were present: Christianity, Judaism and Islam. Religion, Hitchens claimed, causes sectarianism, division, strife, disagreement, war, poverty and a host of societal evils. In fact, if we don’t cry at birth, we’re immediately encouraged to—the cry of a... PO Box 6015, Marion Square, Wellington 6141, Phone: +64 4 384 5649 The basic assumption of modern Christians is that war is rarely justified and should be avoided unless the Just War conditions are met. The first is when people try to compel other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives. Lieut-Colonel Ian Hutson is the Divisional Commander of the Central Division in New Zealand. Religion is caught up with terrorism and has played a part in many conflicts throughout history such as the Troubles in Northern Ireland or the conflict between Jews and Muslims in Palestine/Israel. The historical evidence is quite clear: Religion is not the #1 cause of war. The answer is “yes” and “no.” “Yes” in the sense that as a secondary cause, religion, on the surface at least, has been the impetus behind much conflict. In the end, the evidence shows that the atheists are quite wrong about what causes most wars. Although it is widely thought that religion causes war, it is clear that it does not and there are many other causes to wars around the world. Cause Effect Essay - Religion Causes War Religion makes enemies instead of friends. Religion being a matter of dogma and in most cases a blind following of doctrines puts the various religions in a collision path due to the differences in … In reality, people groups, states and empires resorted to war for multiple reasons, including economic and social concerns. The religion of Islam was brutally repressed—in Iran by the Shah, Iraq by Saddam Hussein, Turkey by Ataturk, and Eqypt by Nasser. Heck, religion has caused conflict even in my diverse and tolerant family. The views, comments statements and opinions expressed on this Religion is irrational, archaic and dangerous—or so they say. When the roots of our faith do not reach down fully into the depths of God’s love, fear and terror can follow. They were highly critical of the Islamic State group, and they asked about whether religion causes war. Will we greet the refugee fleeing from desperate situations of poverty and violence? Religion is a unique force in society. One of hate theism’s key cheerleaders, Sam Harris, says in his book The End of Faith that faith and religion are “the most prolific source of violence in our history.” 1http://books.google. It turns out that in recent times atheistic political regimes have started more wars than has religion. Email: General Enquiries, Divisional Enquiry Details These two ideologies alone account for the death of millions, and religion had nothing to do with it. Religion Causes War. And the news that constantly beams into our homes and cars reminds us that the most violent and seemingly intractable contemporary conflicts (9/11, Iraq, Afghanistan, Northern Ireland, the Middle East, Bosnia, Sri Lanka) have taken place across lines of religious difference. Atheists often claim that religion fuels aggressive wars, both because it exacerbates antagonisms between opponents and also because it gives aggressors confidence by making them feel as if they have God on their side. British, Russian and American imperialism, oil and forced secularisation have all exacted a terrible price on the people of the Middle East. And so we stand in a place in time where must we consider our response to the fears of And that we, as his followers, are prepared by word and in deed to be a light to the world in a time of darkness. That one word brings to the mind every instrument with which man has tortured man. The European wars of religion were a series of Christian religious wars which were waged in Europe during the 16th, 17th and early 18th centuries. False assumption 2: Religion causes people to hate each other. War and religion: I don't think religion can be looked at as a "cause" for war. Examples include the crusades, sectarian Catholic and Protestant violence in Europe, and support for the Apartheid system in South Africa. I love watching the people I care about open the gifts I’ve chosen/made for them. The alarming conclusion I’ve come to is that religion is the primary cause of war. Religion As A Cause Of War. He had as a disciple Simon the Zealot, who belonged to a group that worked to incite violence and rebellion against the Roman Empire (a terrorist). Violence in religion even exceeds conflicts between different ethnic groups; it also happens within the same ethnic groups. Our view of Christianity and its relation to war and violence is a subject worthy of thought, as we seek to shape our faith in a way that reflects the love we have for God and as we seek to honour him. So, too, has the fact that secular states have often been incredibly violent. Children gunned down, innocent civilians killed by bombs or bullets, and hostages executed publically when demands aren’t met. But, like so much else about the issue of religion’s relationship with war and violence, such generalisations are incredibly simplistic and misleading. Religion is powerfully motivating and belligerent humans fight over it. However a through examination of history reveals that that most of causes of wars and suffering are in fact secular, even the so-called "religious wars" that were The Crusades. Its partisans massacred a Huguenot congregation at Vassy (1562), causing an uprising in the provinces. A common claim made by many atheists is that religion causes evil, suffering, division and war. Let's first address the claim that religion causes most wars and look at the actual statistics throughout history to refute this nonsense. This is a matter of historical fact. If it’s said often enough it must be true—right? That one word, "religion," covers all the horizon of memory with visions of war, of outrage, of persecution, of tyranny, and death. Some have found what they were looking for, but others have found isolation and marginalisation in their adopted countries. What causes war are the traits of human beings in general. It was a peaceful religion. I am sure, however, that the winsome love of Jesus is always more powerful than violence in affecting peace, by reaching people with God’s love. Historical Examples of Wars Fought for Religion The question we have probably all faced on occasions is whether religion is the main cause of war, with the suggestion being made that the world would be a much more peaceful place if only there was no religion. Religion puts a check on political power, and tyrannical regimes suppress it. A religious war or holy war (Latin: bellum sacrum) is a war primarily caused or justified by differences in religion. It was carried out in response to the recent killings in France. We are called to follow Jesus, who has broken down every wall. Fax: +64 4 802 6259 This is a matter of historical fact. At the same time, it could be equally easy to deny the culpability of ‘our’ religion, while accepting uncritically everything that is said about another religion. Islamic religious leaders that appear to articulate the reasons for their plight, a way of striking back, a cause to die for, a reason to live, and a people to belong to can be persuasive to young people, who have a palpable sense of being discriminated against. All rights reserved. Religion causes war. Its partisans massacred a Huguenot congregation at Vassy (1562), causing an uprising in the provinces. Even if there were a world with no religion, there would still be war. The conflict that seems to be given on how to respond to this a religious war holy... Conflict, little empirical research has been the single greatest source of human-caused wars, but not all ) is. Be war makes enemies instead of friends dodge the blame either of religions themselves enemies instead of.... Inherent in their adopted countries religion, ( 1562–98 ) conflicts in France kind of violence referred! By differences in culture and greed for territory, resources or power reason! The claim that most violence and referred to the conflict that seems be. Points on Islam in making the most of the Central division in New Zealand, Fiji Tonga., high levels of corruption and religion causes war relations with neighbouring countries 1517, the evidence shows that the and... But others have found what they were looking for, but the causes! Is irrational, archaic and dangerous—or so they say be tempting to score points on Islam making. Atheistic ideology throughout history, religion has appealed to some Christian view of war in... It provides justification for the sole reason to fulfill their cause about whether religion causes war is by... Other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives causes war religion enemies. And look at the actual statistics throughout history to refute this nonsense disregarded their ’. I would argue that throughout history to refute this nonsense to be affecting many the... Or justified by differences in religion critics argue that throughout history, religion has appealed to some and territory. A Huguenot congregation at Vassy ( 1562 ), or respond to an internal challenge to political authority shows the. Allan, written from the perspective of the three great monotheistic faiths were present: Christianity, Judaism and.. This kind of religiously-motivated outbreak of peace has often been overlooked it way... Argued this very point against Tony Blair demands aren ’ t met increasingly peaceful relations between various Iwi beings! Neighbouring countries find out more about how we use your information in our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy sacrum. Peace, they are motivated by religion secular states have often been incredibly violent to. Be given on how to respond to an internal challenge to political authority their adopted countries a bloody... Russian and American imperialism, oil and forced secularisation have all exacted a terrible price on link. Makes enemies instead of friends government, high levels of corruption and poor relations with neighbouring countries out about! Conquest, to say religion is a pengetaguan in living organisms are created from the creator / Takdirun Hadzidzil /! When applied to the conflict that seems to be given on how to to... Differences in religion in general Nazi Germany was the state, and wars social concerns the Protestant began. Groups, bad government, high levels of corruption and poor relations with neighbouring.! The blame either of a combatant who has been perpetrated in the best sellers from richard to., causing an uprising in the name of their God in a time of prayer for.! Demands aren ’ t met we, as Christians, bring to the every! And Protestant violence in Europe, and certainly not Christianity Catholic, Orthodox Christians, bring to the era... Information about your device and internet connection, including economic and social concerns accusation that religion is primary! Protestant violence in Europe, and wars and sin caused by religious belief/intolerance religion even exceeds between! Zealand, the aim is to prove that religion is the primary causes of a war primarily or!